Could a Superfood Help Save Haiti’s Forests?
Haiti is the most impoverished country in the Northern Hemisphere, and trees, or the lack thereof, are part of the problem.
After centuries of agricultural exploitation and the population’s demand for charcoal and fuel wood, 98 percent of Haiti’s landscape is deforested, leaving the country vulnerable to environmental disasters. In 2008, four storms in quick succession resulted in flooding responsible for 800 deaths and $1 billion in damage. The massive earthquake that same year killed more than 220,000 people.
Numerous studies have supported the link between deforestation and poverty in the country. One hundred thousand children under the age of five suffer from acute malnutrition, less than half of households have access to safe water, and one-third of the women and children are anemic. Everyone from conservationists to actor Sean Penn sees trees as the answer. The question is, which trees?
Some believe the answer could be Moringa, a native of the Himalayan foothills in northwestern India and the latest imported ingredient to achieve “superfood” status (see also quinoa, açaí, and chia). The tree—called variously “the miracle tree,” “tree of life,” “mother’s best friend,” and the “never die tree”—can shoot from seed to 15-foot stature in the span of a year; flourishes in hot, dry subtropical climates; and can be put to use from root to pod. Nutritionally, Moringa has more calcium than milk, more vitamin C than oranges, more vitamin A than carrots, more iron than spinach, more potassium than bananas, and just as much protein as eggs.
Could two of Haiti’s problems—deforestation and poverty—be solved by Moringa? It’s a potential solution floated by Oakland, California–based social enterprise company Kuli Kuli, in partnership with the Clinton Foundation and Haitian nonprofit Smallholder Farmers Alliance, to develop a new Moringa supply chain in Haiti. That chain would result in Kuli Kuli’s newest product: a Soul Cycle–appropriate cousin to 5-Hour Energy called Moringa Green Energy Shots, to be sold nationwide at Whole Foods.
Chef José Andrés is in on the action too. His nonprofit organization, World Central Kitchen, is working to improve nutrition in Haiti and other developing nations using Moringa and promoting recipe competition on Instagram using the hashtag #MoringaInspired.
Kuli Kuli has succeeded with this model before. In Ghana, the planting of 60,000 Moringa trees has provided a sustainable livelihood for 500 women farmers for the past three years and enabled Kuli Kuli to launch its Moringa Superfood Bars in stores in the U.S. Kuli Kuli pays 30 percent over the market price, and it prepays for harvests to ensure that the crop remains sustainable.
But while its nutrition benefits are irrefutable, is mass-planting Moringa the right reforestation tactic for Haiti? S. Blair Hedges, director of the Center for Biodiversity at Temple University, doesn’t think so.
“Although it is true that [Moringa oleifera] has benefits for humans (food, medicine), the major claim made, that Haiti would benefit by reforestation with this species, is misleading,” Hedges, whose work preserving Haitian flora and fauna has led to the discovery of several new species of Haitian frogs, wrote in an email.
“Moringa has been grown in Haiti for over 50 years and so is far from being an invasive species,” Kuli Kuli CEO Lisa Curtis told TakePart. “We’re not bringing anything new to the country; we’re simply working with smallholder women farmers to help them plant more Moringa trees and develop an export market for value-added Moringa powder.” The trees, she added, would be grown alongside limes, coffee, and other vegetable crops.
“It would put money in someone’s pocket but would not solve Haiti’s environmental problems or protect Haiti’s rich biodiversity,” Hedges said. That, he added, would require a more local solution.
“A forest full of native Haitian species would do much better in stopping erosion, protecting water resources, and providing food, shelter, and energy for the Haitian people,” he continued.