Should Students Be Graded on Their Weight?

French diet guru Pierre Dukan thinks skinny kids should get extra credit for keeping off the pounds.

January 3, 2012

report card, apple, red sharpie
(Photo: Getty Images)

Here in the States, we're pretty content to just use teaching gardens and Beyonce to try to encourage kids to live a healthier lifestyle.

But French diet guru Pierre Dukan thinks students need something a little more than an R&B diva and some fresh salad greens to motivate them to stay fit.

Dukan—whose protein-packed diet has been embraced by celebs like Kate Middleton and J.Lo—says the only way to really get kids serious about staving off childhood obesity is to hit them where it counts: their report cards.

In his new book, An Open Letter to the Future Presdient, Dukan says that French high schoolers who maintain a healthy Body Mass Index should be given bonus points on the all-important "Bac" exam that all students take to get their diploma. 

Pierre Dukan Photo: Getty Images

The extra credit for skinny kids is a way to "educate teens about a balanced diet," Dukan says in an interview with newspaper Le Parisien [sorry folks, the link's in French].

And he denied that grading kids on their weight would encourage them to develop an unhealthy relationship with food. 

"This wouldn't change anything for those who don't need to lose weight," Dukan told Le Parisien. "And for the others, it will motivate them."

France has one of the lowest rates of adult obesity in the European Union, but politicians and policy makers are concerned about growing waistlines. Among the fat-fighting measures: a new "fat tax" on sugary drinks that took effect in the new year. 

Comments 1

In Europe and other parts of the world, many towns are designed to be walkable and bikeable, and children are encouraged to eat a variety of fruits and vegetables from an early age. In America towns are so spread-out that people will literally drive 5 minutes in a car to buy ice cream because walking takes 20-30 minutes. And kids don't eat healthy if their parents don't. My mom doesn't like okra or eggplant, and my dad doesn't like sweet potatoes. I ate a lot of other vegetables growing up, but I didn't like peppers or tomatoes. Then I went abroad and had all kinds of vegetables cooked in all kinds of delectable sauces, and now I eat any vegetable! I also walked and took public transportation everywhere instead of sitting in a car all the time! But anyway, a lot of parents need education first before you start going after the kids. Go to a restaurant in America and just observe some typical families. If the parents are choosing french fries and entrees heavy on red meats and cheeses, chances are the kids aren't going to pick the salad.